Re: [ee4j-pmc] Specification project scope statements

["Markus KARG" <markus@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

 

All that says is: "Eclipse Proeject for JMS provides the API and TCK for Java™ Message Service (JMS) API, starting from the specification defined by JSR-343."

 

> This is actually a bad example that needs to be changed. It makes no attempt to actually define the scope of JMS. It's basically self-referential.

 

Actually it is not self-referential. The project "Eclipse Project for JMS" is a different thing than "Java Message Service API" itself. One is a group of committers, the other is a technology they work on. The cause of this "self-referenceis that "somebody" decided that all projects for Java EE technology are named "Eclipse Project for X". It would be more clear if the sentence would read like "Eclipse Hermes provides the API and TCK for JMS, the official standard for MOM drivers on the Java platform.".

 

So what do you actually want to have, a description of the project or a description of the technology?