Per,
21+ committers is a lot of committers - are these people actually doing
anything? Have these new committers demonstrated their ability to
follow the project's processes? Do they write good code? Good
documentation? Has their work been peer reviewed? I don't see any of
that evidence on the mailing list.
I quote from the Charter
(http://www.eclipse.org/projects/dev_process/Eclipse_Standard_TopLevel_Charter_v1.0.php)
- Developers who give frequent and valuable contributions to a
Project, ... can have their status
promoted to that of a "Committer" for that Project or component
respectively.
- Active participation in the user newsgroup and the appropriate
developer
mailing lists is a responsibility of all Committers, ...
- Becoming a Committer
is a privilege that is earned by contributing and showing discipline
and good
judgment. It is a responsibility that should be neither given nor taken
lightly.
Please clarify the situation here.
Thanks,
Bjorn
Per Kroll wrote:
Hi,
I hereby notify the PMC about a yes
vote for the 9 new committers listed below.
Last week, we also voted yes on 5
new
committers per
http://dev.eclipse.org/mhonarc/lists/epf-dev/msg00022.html
Finally, the EPF team before that
had
7 committers. This provides us with a total of 21 committers elected.
More committers are expected to be
voted
in after the next face-to-face committer meeting in Bilbao, Spain on
March
6-7.
Finally, we also plan to have a 3rd
committer face-to-face meeting in conjunction with EclipseConn on March
23-24.
Thanks
Per Kroll
STSM, Manager Methods: RUP / RMC
Project Lead: Eclipse Process Framework
Rational Software, IBM Corp
408-342-3815
----- Forwarded by
Per
Kroll/Cupertino/IBM on 02/27/2006 12:01 PM -----
| Per
Kroll/Cupertino/IBM
02/27/2006 12:00 PM
|
|
The following people have been voted
in as committers, with 3 yes, and 0 obstain and vetos.
- Kurt Sand - Telelogic
- Chris Sibbald - Telelogic
- Brian Haughton – BearingPoint
- Bruce MacIsaac - IBM
- Jim Ruehlin - IBM
- Todd Fredrickson - IBM
- Naveena Bereny - IBM
- Scott Ambler - AmbySoft
- DJ de Villiers - Ivar Jacobson
International
Voting record are per the following
links
http://dev.eclipse.org/mhonarc/lists/epf-dev/msg00020.html
http://dev.eclipse.org/mhonarc/lists/epf-dev/msg00021.html
http://dev.eclipse.org/mhonarc/lists/epf-dev/msg00026.html
I will now notify the PMC of the
results,
and tomorrow fill in the forms on behalf of the PMC.
Thanks
Per Kroll
STSM, Manager Methods: RUP / RMC
Project Lead: Eclipse Process Framework
Rational Software, IBM Corp
408-342-3815
----- Forwarded by
Per
Kroll/Cupertino/IBM on 02/27/2006 11:57 AM -----
| Per
Kroll/Cupertino/IBM
02/20/2006 01:54 PM
|
|
Hi,
we need to vote on new committers,
batch
2. We need 3 yes, and no veto to accept a new committer.
I am voting yes through this e-mail.
If there are other people that
expect
to become committers, but are not on the list below, please send me a
note
asap and we will do one more vote. I do not want to vote on people that
are still iffy on whether they will be committers or not, and I know
many
organizations are still finalizing who should be a committer.
The following people have voting
rights
(and no others need to reply):
- Peter Haumer
- Ricardo Balduino
- Jim Thario
- Per Kroll
- Charlie Yan
- Kelvin Low
- Jao Tham
We need +3 of you to respond with
Yes.
You can also Obstain or Veto. If you veto, you need to provide a reason
for your veto within 24 hours, or your veto is ignored.
<The people that were voted on
last
week has not yet become confirmed committers, and does hence not yet
have
the right to vote. I am filing the forms (#3 on
http://www.eclipse.org/legal/newcommitter.php)
for you today, and if you have done #2, and #4, it should only take a
few
more days.>
- Kurt Sand - Telelogic
- Chris Sibbald - Telelogic
- Brian Haughton – BearingPoint
- Bruce MacIsaac - IBM
- Jim Ruehlin - IBM
- Todd Fredrickson - IBM
- Naveena Bereny - IBM
- Scott Ambler - AmbySoft
- DJ de Villiers - Ivar Jacobson
International
Again, if you expected your name
here,
and it is not, it is because I am still uncertain of whether you are
firm
as a committer. Please send me a note confirming that you should be a
committer.
For those in Europe that has
expressed
interest, but have not yet had a chance to become fully engaged, we may
wait until you had a chance to attend the March 6-7 meeting before
making
you committers.
Thanks
Per Kroll
STSM, Manager Methods: RUP / RMC
Project Lead: Eclipse Process Framework
Rational Software, IBM Corp
408-342-3815
_______________________________________________
technology-pmc mailing list
technology-pmc@xxxxxxxxxxx
https://dev.eclipse.org/mailman/listinfo/technology-pmc
|
