Hi,
Well, considering the status of the RSARTE import tool (disregarding this discussion about the status of what it depends on), I would not like to see it leave incubation. I don't think that the import tools is mature enough to let it leave incubation.
To be honest, I am not sure that I think that the RSA import tool should leave incubation either, and from my earlier understanding, it would still be in incubation. I guess the version numbering just follows along the old version number from when it was part of the extras components of Papyrus for which a lot of them left incubation too early. This as I have understood is what they have tried to correct with moving out stuff into separate repos, e.g. the incubation repo for stuff that really should be incubation. I also thought that the interoperability repo would be in incubation. But I guess this is something that really needs to be checked with the Papyrus project if it really have left incubation already.
Anyway, the discussion we have had so far has been to leave RSARTE migration in incubation. See for example the discussion in
bug 513384 where we left the wording "Incubation" for the RSARTE migration feature.
But I am probably not the right one to make this call whether it should graduating or stay in incubation. Personally I think we will send the completely wrong message to the community if we stated that it was graduating, because it is not mature enough and people would just get the wrong expectations if we did graduate it prematurely.
/Peter Cigéhn