Re: [ecf-dev] Re: Riena Creation Review 19th Dec 2007

[Scott Lewis <slewis@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

Hi Jeff,

 McAffer wrote:

I really want to avoid pitting one project against another and ranking technologies or implementations.  We should sort this out in the broader context of Equinox/Eclipse RT (the new top level project) and look at the problems from the consumer point of view. 

Agreed. 

Taking that approach things like the EEG work in this area become very relevant. 

Yes...agreed.  To the extent possible given the membership structure and individual/corporate considerations I and Jan Rellermeyer and Markus Kuppe are participating in the EEG work...specifically on RFC 119. 

As such we should be focussing on ensuring that that spec is reasonable and meets our needs.  If it does not, now is the time to speak up and drive the spec.

Yes.  We will continue to do this.

 From there we can have many different implementations and approaches.  As long as they play well together then our consumers are happy.

Yes.  Agreed.

Scott