| [technology-pmc] WG: [dataspaceconnector-dev] Committer Election for Dr. Markus Lehmann on Eclipse Dataspace Connector has started |
|
Hopefully no double post, since I got a refusion mail for technology-pmc on the last attempt. I completely understand the feedback, as the aspect of transparency is important here and the issue, since we kind of expected such feedback, has already been discussed in advance in the project
team. In the case of Markus Lehmann, the situation is indeed somewhat special, as his documented activities are not visible directly in the EDC repository, but within the environment of the Catena-X project. The contributions mentioned (concepts, diagrams,
workshop results) were thereby transferred by other people, which in retrospect was a mistake with regard to this discussion. As Catena-X being a lighthouse project for the use of the EDC, one can see the high benefit from Markus' work in the daily project life, but of course not from the perspective of the EF, the PMC
and prospective contributors. My suggestion would be to (further) actively involve Markus in the work and discussions of the EDC committers and to make sure to document his contributions more transparently in the future. With
visible contributions, we will again start the election. Markus Von: dataspaceconnector-dev <dataspaceconnector-dev-bounces@xxxxxxxxxxx> im Auftrag von Wayne Beaton <wayne.beaton@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> Elections serve, in part, as a transparent demonstration to prospective contributors of what the project team considers to be sufficient merit to join. It also serves as a transparent demonstration that the
candidate has demonstrated that they understand the project well enough to take on the responsibility of being a committer. To that end, please be as specific as possible when you're describing merit. AFAICT, this candidate has not signed the ECA and has made no contributions to the project via Git, nor do I see any contributions via issues or pull requests on any project repositories. Is there any public record of the contributions that you've cited in the nomination statement? Wayne On Thu, Apr 21, 2022 at 2:23 AM <emo@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
Wayne Beaton Director of Open Source Projects |
Eclipse Foundation
My working day may not be your working day! Please don’t feel obliged to read or reply to this e-mail outside of your normal working hours. |