| [tcf-dev] Evaluating expression : Best practise ? |
Hi Eugene, We have a command-line tool that implements the GdbType / GdbValue like GDB with the Python interface.One design rule was to avoid using Expression Create to get the various sub-fields
like the IDE is doing (see below) for performance reason and to make it more language agnostic. The idea was to: Expression create "structure" Expression evaluate : We get the "dump" of the structure + some types info. Loop within the Types and send Symbols getContext / getChildren.Retrieve the field value through the "Offset" property (which is the "index" in the "dump") and display it according to the type.
I'm not sure it's a good idea, especially since the Expression service does:- Indirect Evaluation (for AT_data_location). In such case, the "dump" will be incomplete.
- Only expression service is able to return complex infos like
"Pieces":[{"BitSize":1,"Address":1745100492}]
(Which is the case for the bit_field sample here)
Please see the attached zip file.
We have some comments in bit_fields.txt.
The questions are there : "would expect to have following properties :
"Pieces":[{"BitSize":15,"BitOffs":1,"Address":1745100492}]"
Are our expectations too high for Symbols getContext ?I think it could work on simple structure when "Offset" is returned by getContext but won't in case of complex replies (using Pieces) or won't work if it requieres indirection (like AT_data_location).
In other words, should our tool mimic the IDE like this:
Expression Create "structure"
Issue some Symbols getContext / getChildren and for each field:
Expression create "CTX" null (${structId}).${fieldId})"
Expression evaluate to the field value
Symbol getContext to get the field type
Moreover, we are not fully clear about when to use:
Expressions getChildren (seem to deal with stacktrace to retrieve arguments)
vs
Symbols getChildren (what we believe we must use to dump structure)
Can you please comment on this and provide guidance ?
Many thanks,
Xavier.
Attachment:
logs.tar.gz
Description: application/gzip