[
Date Prev][
Date Next][
Thread Prev][
Thread Next][
Date Index][
Thread Index]
[
List Home]
Re: [mylyn-reviews-dev] Automatically generating Review Items from SCM
|
Hello
Oliver,
Yes
this is a very good idea, we also had other users suggesting something
similar.
In
general we are very open to new suggestions, ideas etc. Can you please
file a bug on R4E in bugzilla, with a detailed description on how you envision
the new functionality or any other pertinent info? We will then discuss it
within the team and eventually add it to our backlog.
BR,
/Sebastien
Thank you Sebastien,
In my oppinion, it would be nice to also add this feature to R4E, and I
hope that it will be done at some time.
Best regards,
Oliver
Hi,
At the moment the functionality you are describing is not available as is in
R4E. However some of what you are looking for ould partly be achieved
e.g.
- You
can assign specific Review Items (i.e. commits) to specific people to
review
- You
can define a list of people that could be added as participants together to
reviews in the R4E preference, which are shareable among multiple
users.
- You
can include specific SCM commits as review items. We currently support Git
and SVN (Subclipse) as SCM providers.
Typically the way the review process work with R4E is as
follow:
1) A
person (we would call him/her the review lead) creates the review as a child to
a preconfigured Review Group
2)
This person adds the review contents (one or more commits or manually selected
items)
3)
This person also add the people that will be part of the review (reviewers,
authors etc.) and notifies them, using automatic
R4E notifications
4) The
reviewers review the code and write anomalies on the review
contents
5)
Authors/Developers correct the code if applicable according to the
anomalies
6) The
lead that added the corrected code in the review as new review
items
7)
Repeat steps 4-5 (and 2) until all issues are
addressed/resolved
8) The
lead closes the review and generates a review report that can be
archived.
Best
Regards,
Sebastien Dubois (on behalf of the R4E development
team)
Dear all,
I have one general question regarding the functionality of R4E. Will it be
possible to automatically generate Review Items from SCM commits?
What we would like to use is actually the ReviewClipse functionality:
1. Configure globally, which team members review which other team
members
2. A team member can open an eclipse view with all commits from other team
members she has to review according to the global configuration
3. Reviews are thus done for specific SCM revisions and result in Mylyn
Tasks.
Will the classical ReviewClipse functionality supported by R4E?
Thank you and best regards,
Oliver
Kühne + Nagel (AG & Co.) KG, Geschäftsleitung:
Hans-Georg Brinkmann (Vors.), Dirk Blesius, Reiner Heiken, Holger Ketz
(Stellv.), Jan-Hendrik Köstergarten (Stellv.), Bruno Mang, Christian Marnetté,
Jens Wollesen, Sitz: Bremen, Registergericht: Bremen, HRA 21928, USt-IdNr.: DE
812773878, Persönlich haftende Gesellschaft: Kühne & Nagel A.G., Sitz:
Contern/Luxemburg Geschäftsführender Verwaltungsrat: Karl
Gernandt