[
Date Prev][
Date Next][
Thread Prev][
Thread Next][
Date Index][
Thread Index]
[
List Home]
Re: [microprofile-wg] MicroProfile 7.0 Ballot verbiage straw poll
|
Proposal 5 (iJUG)
Why:
Proposal 1 is not safe in all intended
cases, while some aspects could be helpful for releasing
Proposal 3 is safe, but could be
stricter than necessary in some cases
Proposal 5 tries to deliver a
compromise between the two (1 and 3).
Proposal 4 is a bigger organisational
change, that could be handled separately.
We had a very good discussion at the
last technical call, I think we need to continue this.
And I think we do not run out of time
for MP 7.0(.0), because the already foreseeable breaking changes
in the Jakarta Core Profile (like Java SE 21 minimum, JPMS
Requirements, Jakarta REST 4.0) will not allow the Proposal 1 way
of shortcut - I expect we will have to do a MP 8.0(.0) anyway.
It might be helpful for the ongoing
discussion to separate out things we can agree on easier or where
technical constraints give the answer, like:
- Component spec relation (to component
specs only, not to umbrella specs)
- Umbrella spec relation (i.e. to
umbrella specs of type provided - this depends on JPMS
constraints)
- Full support of Semantic Versioning
- Moving all the specs to Jakarta
(Proposal 4)
I hope this will bring us further. Most
of the aspects would be relevant for Jakarta too, so it should be
discussed there and with them at some point.
Best,
Jan
Am 19.05.23 um 19:24 schrieb John
Clingan:
Further
to the previous email announcement,
here is the Straw Poll for choosing the most popular proposals
among proposal 1, 3 and 5.
A
Steering Committee Representatives vote is requested. Please
respond with ONE of the following based on your opinion:
Proposal
1: MicroProfile releases support a minimum Jakarta EE
versions
Proposal
3: Release new MicroProfile versions when new Jakarta
EE/Java SE LTS versions are released
Proposal
5: Release new MicroProfile versions following Semantic
Versioning rules and adopt new Jakarta EE (and Java SE
LTS) releases accordingly
Any
feedback that you can provide to support your vote
will be appreciated.
Please
reply with "proposal number and organization name
("community" for community members). Example: "1
(Acme Corporation)". Feel free to start a separate
thread for discussion. This straw poll runs for
seven days, so it ends on May 26th 2023. Community
input and Community votes are welcomed. However,
only the votes delivered by Steering Committee
Representatives will be counted towards the ballot
verbiage outlined in the linked announcement above.
_______________________________________________
microprofile-wg mailing list
microprofile-wg@xxxxxxxxxxx
To change your delivery options, retrieve your password, or unsubscribe from this list, visit
https://www.eclipse.org/mailman/listinfo/microprofile-wg