Re: [gemini-dev] DBAccess Graduation document

["Kissner, Juergen" <juergen.kissner@xxxxxxx>]

Hi Mike,

 

thanks for your comments --- I've included them in the document.

 

Finding a way to change the document title (and especially the author) meta data took me a while.

 

You did not like the "Compliant with JDBC 3 and JDBC 4"? It was meant to express that DBAccess does not cause incompatibilities/problems with JDBC or makes it more difficult to use JDBC.  Maybe that is my (non-native speaker) misinterpretation of the word  compliant.

 

--Juergen

 

 

 

From: Mike Keith [mailto:michael.keith@xxxxxxxxxx]
Sent: Dienstag, 8. Februar 2011 22:55
To: Gemini and sub-projects developer discussions
Cc: Kissner, Juergen
Subject: Re: [gemini-dev] DBAccess Graduation document

 

Hi Juergen,

I think you're close. A few comments:

- You should change the title of the presentation to not be "RCP Applications"

- Some of the slides seem a little empty. Just as an FYI, apparently "information dense" is a good thing (http://wiki.eclipse.org/Development_Resources/FAQs/About_Docuware).

- the copyright should be you or SAP, not Eclipse Foundation

- Slide 4
    - Technically, DBAccess supports Derby, not Java DB (I'm sure Java DB will work, but it is not exactly the same)
    - Support for MySQL should not be "in progress". Either you plan for it to be there by the time the review happens or you don't (in which case you should take it out of the preso)

- Slide 7
    - Not sure if I would include the OSGi Core spec as part of the project user documentation.

- Slide 10
    -  Might want to put some explanation about why there is no tooling

- Slide 13
    - really only compliant with the JDBC chapter of OSGi 4.2

-Mike

On 1/31/2011 9:45 AM, Kissner, Juergen wrote:

Hi,

like Costin, I used the Eclipse Release Review template to create a document for DBAccess.

I have also added and extended various (wiki-) pages of the DBAccess project.

 

Feedback and comments are welcome.

 

-- Juergen

 

 

 

_______________________________________________

gemini-dev mailing list

gemini-dev@xxxxxxxxxxx

https://dev.eclipse.org/mailman/listinfo/gemini-dev

Attachment: Gemini-DBAccess-Graduation-1.0.0-ReleaseReview-r1.odp
Description: Gemini-DBAccess-Graduation-1.0.0-ReleaseReview-r1.odp

Attachment: Gemini-DBAccess-Graduation-1.0.0-ReleaseReview-r1.pdf
Description: Gemini-DBAccess-Graduation-1.0.0-ReleaseReview-r1.pdf