Skip to main content
[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index] [List Home]
Re: [ee4j-pmc] git release tags
Nice catch, Bill!  We should be removing the "-RELEASE" suffix.  That's just plain ugly...  :-)


---------------------------------------------------
Kevin Sutter
STSM, MicroProfile and Java EE architect
e-mail:  sutter@xxxxxxxxxx     Twitter:  @kwsutter
phone: tl-553-3620 (office), 507-253-3620 (office)    
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/kevinwsutter



From:        arjan tijms <arjan.tijms@xxxxxxxxx>
To:        ee4j-pmc PMC List <ee4j-pmc@xxxxxxxxxxx>
Date:        11/28/2018 01:22 AM
Subject:        Re: [ee4j-pmc] git release tags
Sent by:        ee4j-pmc-bounces@xxxxxxxxxxx





On Wed, Nov 28, 2018 at 1:09 AM Bill Shannon <bill.shannon@xxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
tags, quite a few of which don't follow the recommendation.  The most
common divergence by far is to follow the release number with "-RELEASE".

I think this is because it was simply in the original release script that many (most?) people copied:

RELEASE_TAG="${RELEASE_VERSION}-RELEASE"
echo "Current version: ${SNAPSHOT_VERSION}"
echo "Release version: ${RELEASE_VERSION}"
echo "Next version:    ${NEXT_VERSION}"
echo "Release tag:     ${RELEASE_TAG}"

For instance, JSF/Mojarra has this release:

https://github.com/eclipse-ee4j/mojarra/releases/tag/2.3.9-RELEASE

But this branch:

https://github.com/eclipse-ee4j/mojarra/tree/2.3.9

And this Maven version:

https://oss.sonatype.org/content/repositories/staging/org/glassfish/jakarta.faces/2.3.9

I'm all for having consistent numbers though among the various projects.

Kind regards,
Arjan





FYI, the only GitHub releases I found were for yasson, jaf, and javamail.

Here's the tags I found, ignoring the -M and -RC tags:

common-annotations-api: 1.3.3-RELEASE bad release name
common-annotations-api: 1.3.4-RELEASE bad release name
concurrency-api: 1.1.1-RELEASE bad release name
concurrency-ri: 1.1.1-RELEASE bad release name
eclipselink: 1.0.0 ok
eclipselink: 1.0.1 ok
eclipselink: 1.0.2 ok
eclipselink: 1.1.0 ok
eclipselink: 1.1.1 ok
eclipselink: 1.1.2 ok
eclipselink: 1.1.3 ok
eclipselink: 1.1.4 ok
eclipselink: 1.2.0 ok
eclipselink: 2.0.0 ok
eclipselink: 2.0.1 ok
eclipselink: 2.0.2 ok
eclipselink: 2.1.0 ok
eclipselink: 2.1.1 ok
eclipselink: 2.1.1-2.1.1 bad release name
eclipselink: 2.1.2 ok
eclipselink: 2.1.3 ok
eclipselink: 2.2.0 ok
eclipselink: 2.2.1 ok
eclipselink: 2.3.0 ok
eclipselink: 2.3.1 ok
eclipselink: 2.3.2 ok
eclipselink: 2.3.3 ok
eclipselink: 2.4.0 ok
eclipselink: 2.4.1 ok
eclipselink: 2.4.1-release bad release name
eclipselink: 2.4.2 ok
eclipselink: 2.5.0 ok
eclipselink: 2.5.1 ok
eclipselink: 2.5.2 ok
eclipselink: 2.6.0 ok
eclipselink: 2.6.0_WAS bad release name
eclipselink: 2.6.1 ok
eclipselink: 2.6.1_WAS bad release name
eclipselink: 2.6.2 ok
eclipselink: 2.6.2_WAS bad release name
eclipselink: 2.6.3 ok
eclipselink: 2.6.3_WAS bad release name
eclipselink: 2.6.4 ok
eclipselink: 2.6.5 ok
eclipselink: 2.7.0 ok
eclipselink: 2.7.1 ok
eclipselink: 2.7.2 ok
eclipselink: 2.7.3 ok
eclipselink: bug13651722 bad release name
eclipselink-oracleddlparser: IOT bad release name
eclipselink-workbench: 2.0.0 ok
eclipselink-workbench: 2.1.0 ok
eclipselink-workbench: 2.2.0 ok
eclipselink-workbench: 2.3.0 ok
eclipselink-workbench: 2.4.0 ok
eclipselink-workbench: 2.6.0 ok
eclipselink-workbench: 2.6.0_WAS bad release name
eclipselink-workbench: 2.7.0 ok
eclipselink-workbench: 2.7.1 ok
ee4j: 1.0.1 ok
ee4j: 1.0.2 ok
ee4j: 1.0.3 ok
ee4j: 1.0.4 ok
ee4j: 1.0.5 ok
ejb-api: 3.2.3-RELEASE bad release name
el-ri: 3.0.2-RELEASE bad release name
enterprise-deployment: 1.7.1-RELEASE bad release name
enterprise-deployment: 1.8-RELEASE bad release name
glassfish-fighterfish: MODULE--OSGI-CDI--1.0.6-RELEASE bad release name
glassfish-fighterfish: MODULE--OSGI-CDI-API--1.0.2-RELEASE bad release name
glassfish-fighterfish: MODULE--OSGI-EE-RESOURCES--2.0.2-RELEASE bad release name
glassfish-fighterfish: MODULE--OSGI-EJB-CONTAINER--1.0.5-RELEASE bad release nam
e
glassfish-fighterfish: MODULE--OSGI-HTTP--1.0.8-RELEASE bad release name
glassfish-fighterfish: MODULE--OSGI-JAVAEE-BASE--1.0.9-RELEASE bad release name
glassfish-fighterfish: MODULE--OSGI-JDBC--1.0.3-RELEASE bad release name
glassfish-fighterfish: MODULE--OSGI-JPA--1.0.4-RELEASE bad release name
glassfish-fighterfish: MODULE--OSGI-JPA-EXTENSION--1.0.4-RELEASE bad release nam
e
glassfish-fighterfish: MODULE--OSGI-JTA--1.0.3-RELEASE bad release name
glassfish-fighterfish: MODULE--OSGI-WEB-CONTAINER--2.0.2-RELEASE bad release nam
e
glassfish-fighterfish: MODULE--PARENT-POM--1.0.7-RELEASE bad release name
glassfish-ha-api: 3.1.12-RELEASE bad release name
glassfish-hk2: 2.5.0-RELEASE bad release name
glassfish-hk2: 2.5.0-b63-RELEASE bad release name
glassfish-hk2-extra: 1.0.3-RELEASE bad release name
glassfish-jsftemplating: 2.1.4-RELEASE bad release name
glassfish-logging-annotation-processor: 1.9-RELEASE bad release name
glassfish-shoal: 1.6.53-RELEASE bad release name
grizzly: 2.4.4-RELEASE bad release name
grizzly-npn: 1.9-RELEASE bad release name
grizzly-thrift: grizzly-thrift-1.3.14 bad release name
interceptor-api: 1.2.3-RELEASE bad release name
jacc: 1.6.1-RELEASE bad release name
jacc: 1.7-RELEASE bad release name
jaf: 1.2.1 ok
jaspic: 1.1.2-RELEASE bad release name
javamail: 1.6.3 ok
jax-rpc-api: 1.1.3-RELEASE bad release name
jax-rpc-ri: 1.1.5-RELEASE bad release name
jax-ws-api: 2.3.2-RELEASE bad release name
jaxb-api: 2.3.2-RELEASE bad release name
jaxb-dtd-parser: 1.4.1-RELEASE bad release name
jaxb-dtd-parser: 1.5.0-RELEASE bad release name
jaxb-fi: 1.2.16-RELEASE bad release name
jaxb-fi: 1.2.16-a01-RELEASE bad release name
jaxb-istack-commons: 3.0.8-RELEASE bad release name
jaxb-ri: 2.3.2-CodeModel-RELEASE bad release name
jaxb-ri: 2.3.2-External-RELEASE bad release name
jaxb-ri: 2.3.2-RELEASE bad release name
jaxb-ri: 2.4.0-RELEASE bad release name
jaxb-ri: codemodel-2.3.2-RELEASE bad release name
jaxb-stax-ex: 1.8.1-RELEASE bad release name
jaxb-stax-ex: 1.9.0-RELEASE bad release name
jaxr-api: 1.0.9-RELEASE bad release name
jaxrs-api: 2.1.1 ok
jaxrs-api: 2.1.2 ok
jaxrs-api: 2.1.3 ok
jca-api: 1.7.2-RELEASE bad release name
jms-api: 2.0.1-RELEASE bad release name
jms-api: 2.0.2-RELEASE bad release name
jpa-api: 2.2.1-RELEASE bad release name
jpa-api: 2.2.2-RELEASE bad release name
jsonb-api: 1.0.1-RELEASE bad release name
jsonp: 1.1.3 ok
jsonp: 1.1.3-RELEASE bad release name
jsonp: 1.1.4-RELEASE bad release name
jsonp: 1.1.5-RELEASE bad release name
jsp-api: 2.3.4-RELEASE bad release name
jstl-api: 1.2.3-RELEASE bad release name
jta-api: 1.3.1-RELEASE bad release name
jws-api: 1.1.1-RELEASE bad release name
management-api: 1.1.3-RELEASE bad release name
metro-jax-ws: 2.3.2-RELEASE bad release name
metro-mimepull: 1.9.11-RELEASE bad release name
metro-package-rename-task: 1.5.2-RELEASE bad release name
metro-policy: 2.7.6-RELEASE bad release name
metro-policy: 2.8.0-RELEASE bad release name
metro-saaj: 1.5.1-RELEASE bad release name
metro-ws-test-harness: 2.3.2-RELEASE bad release name
metro-ws-test-harness: 2.4.0-RELEASE bad release name
metro-xmlstreambuffer: 1.5.7-RELEASE bad release name
mojarra: 2.3.3.102 ok
mojarra: 2.3.9-RELEASE bad release name
openmq: 5.1.3-RELEASE bad release name
orb-gmbal-commons: 3.2.1-RELEASE bad release name
orb-gmbal-pfl: 4.0.1-RELEASE bad release name
saaj-api: 1.4.1-RELEASE bad release name
saaj-api: 1.5.0-RELEASE bad release name
security-api: 1.0.1-RELEASE bad release name
servlet-api: 4.0.2-RELEASE bad release name
soteria: 1.0.1-RELEASE bad release name
tyrus: 1.15-RELEASE bad release name
tyrus: 2.0-RELEASE bad release name
websocket-api: 1.1.1-RELEASE bad release name
yasson: 1.0 ok
yasson: 1.0.2-RELEASE bad release name
yasson: 1.0.3-RELEASE bad release name
yasson: yasson-1.0.1 bad release name
_______________________________________________
ee4j-pmc mailing list
ee4j-pmc@xxxxxxxxxxx
To change your delivery options, retrieve your password, or unsubscribe from this list, visit
https://www.eclipse.org/mailman/listinfo/ee4j-pmc_______________________________________________
ee4j-pmc mailing list
ee4j-pmc@xxxxxxxxxxx
To change your delivery options, retrieve your password, or unsubscribe from this list, visit
https://www.eclipse.org/mailman/listinfo/ee4j-pmc



Back to the top