Home » Modeling » EMF "Technology" (Ecore Tools, EMFatic, etc) » OCL compilation
|
| Re: OCL compilation [message #49196 is a reply to message #48987] |
Thu, 07 September 2006 19:29   |
Eclipse User |
|
|
|
Originally posted by: cdamus.ca.ibm.com
Hi, Laurent,
You raise some good problems. You may want to add yourself to the cc list
of an existing bug:
https://bugs.eclipse.org/bugs/show_bug.cgi?id=144210
regarding providing a public API for parsing OCL documents. Evidently, the
internal API that you are currently using also has problems.
Could you please raise bugs for:
- the problem in the grammar file of classifier context not replicating
invOrDefCS
- the exception complaining that the 'self' context cannot be redefined
I can't promise fixes in time for the 1.0.1 release, but we'll see.
Thanks,
Christian
Laurent Le Goff wrote:
> Hello,
> I would like to extends my meta-model with constraints AND new Operation.
> I've chosen OCL language.
> I have some trouble to compile OCL expressions.
> I want to edit an ocl file like this :
> package test
> context TestClass def:
> test1(t:String): String =
> 'coucou1'.concat(t)
> def:
> test2(t:String): String =
> 'coucou2'.concat(t)
> endpackage
>
> I've tried to compile these definition. the Parser send me an error :
> misplace construct. I've rewritten the OCL with only one definition :
> package test
> context TestClass def:
> test1(t:String): String =
> 'coucou'.concat(t)
> endpackage
>
> The parser compile this expression with success. And I can invoke test2
> operation later, GREAT!
>
> PROBLEM :
> I would like to define and compile some OCL constraints or operation (inv
> or def) from files. And call these operations or constraints from other
> files or String like this
>
> IOCLHelper helper = HelperUtil.createOCLHelper();
> EObject context = (EObject)resource.getContents().get(0);
> helper.setContext(TestPackage.eINSTANCE.getTestClass());
>
> OCLExpression exp;
> // where exp is the compilation of the OCL file with constraints and
> operation
> exp = ExpressionsFactory.eINSTANCE.createOCLExpression(expressionS tring);
> System.out.println(helper.evaluate(context, "self.test1('toto')"));
> System.out.println(helper.evaluate(context, "self.test2('toto')"));
>
> ** First I've look at the grammar in your OCL plugin (OCLLPGParser.g
> :lpg grammar) and I think that this grammar block me (extended bnf
> :notation):
>
> package -> 'package' pathName context+ 'endpackage'
> | context*
>
> context -> classifierContext
> | operationContext
> | propertyContext
>
> classifierContext -> context pathName invOrDef
> ...
>
> * I would need this :
>
> classifierContext -> context pathName invOrDef+
>
> ** Secondly I've tried to do this in another way, I've rewritten the code
> : package test
> context TestClass def:
> test1(t:String): String =
> 'coucou1'.concat(t)
> context TestClass def:
> test2(t:String): String =
> 'coucou2'.concat(t)
> endpackage
>
> The parser accept this code but there's an exception thrown that tell me
> that 'self' (context) can't be redefined.
>
> The only solution that I saw is to re-run the parser with each new 'def'
> or 'inv:'. I don't like this solution.
>
> Please, Does anybody know how can I find the good way to compile OCL
> Expressions?
>
> Sorry for the long mail.
> Thanks for any helps
>
> Regards
> Laurent
|
|
|
| Re: OCL compilation [message #49234 is a reply to message #49196] |
Fri, 08 September 2006 07:53 |
 Laurent LE GOFF
Messages: 15
Registered: July 2009 |
Junior Member |
|
|
hello Christian,
thanks for your answer. I entered bugs in bugzilla:
* grammar restriction
https://bugs.eclipse.org/bugs/show_bug.cgi?id=156656
* 'self' cannot be redefine
https://bugs.eclipse.org/bugs/show_bug.cgi?id=156657
I hope that bugs will have to be resolved in the next version ;-)
Regards
Laurent
Le Thu, 07 Sep 2006 15:29:00 -0400, Christian W. Damus a écrit :
>
> Hi, Laurent,
>
> You raise some good problems. You may want to add yourself to the cc list
> of an existing bug:
>
> https://bugs.eclipse.org/bugs/show_bug.cgi?id=144210
>
> regarding providing a public API for parsing OCL documents. Evidently, the
> internal API that you are currently using also has problems.
>
> Could you please raise bugs for:
> - the problem in the grammar file of classifier context not replicating
> invOrDefCS
> - the exception complaining that the 'self' context cannot be redefined
>
> I can't promise fixes in time for the 1.0.1 release, but we'll see.
>
> Thanks,
>
> Christian
>
>
> Laurent Le Goff wrote:
>
>> Hello,
>> I would like to extends my meta-model with constraints AND new Operation.
>> I've chosen OCL language.
>> I have some trouble to compile OCL expressions.
>> I want to edit an ocl file like this :
>> package test
>> context TestClass def:
>> test1(t:String): String =
>> 'coucou1'.concat(t)
>> def:
>> test2(t:String): String =
>> 'coucou2'.concat(t)
>> endpackage
>>
>> I've tried to compile these definition. the Parser send me an error :
>> misplace construct. I've rewritten the OCL with only one definition :
>> package test
>> context TestClass def:
>> test1(t:String): String =
>> 'coucou'.concat(t)
>> endpackage
>>
>> The parser compile this expression with success. And I can invoke test2
>> operation later, GREAT!
>>
>> PROBLEM :
>> I would like to define and compile some OCL constraints or operation (inv
>> or def) from files. And call these operations or constraints from other
>> files or String like this
>>
>> IOCLHelper helper = HelperUtil.createOCLHelper();
>> EObject context = (EObject)resource.getContents().get(0);
>> helper.setContext(TestPackage.eINSTANCE.getTestClass());
>>
>> OCLExpression exp;
>> // where exp is the compilation of the OCL file with constraints and
>> operation
>> exp = ExpressionsFactory.eINSTANCE.createOCLExpression(expressionS tring);
>> System.out.println(helper.evaluate(context, "self.test1('toto')"));
>> System.out.println(helper.evaluate(context, "self.test2('toto')"));
>>
>> ** First I've look at the grammar in your OCL plugin (OCLLPGParser.g
>> :lpg grammar) and I think that this grammar block me (extended bnf
>> :notation):
>>
>> package -> 'package' pathName context+ 'endpackage'
>> | context*
>>
>> context -> classifierContext
>> | operationContext
>> | propertyContext
>>
>> classifierContext -> context pathName invOrDef
>> ...
>>
>> * I would need this :
>>
>> classifierContext -> context pathName invOrDef+
>>
>> ** Secondly I've tried to do this in another way, I've rewritten the code
>> : package test
>> context TestClass def:
>> test1(t:String): String =
>> 'coucou1'.concat(t)
>> context TestClass def:
>> test2(t:String): String =
>> 'coucou2'.concat(t)
>> endpackage
>>
>> The parser accept this code but there's an exception thrown that tell me
>> that 'self' (context) can't be redefined.
>>
>> The only solution that I saw is to re-run the parser with each new 'def'
>> or 'inv:'. I don't like this solution.
>>
>> Please, Does anybody know how can I find the good way to compile OCL
>> Expressions?
>>
>> Sorry for the long mail.
>> Thanks for any helps
>>
>> Regards
>> Laurent
|
|
|
| Re: OCL compilation [message #590462 is a reply to message #48987] |
Thu, 07 September 2006 19:29 |
| Eclipse User |
|
|
|
Originally posted by: cdamus.ca.ibm.com
Hi, Laurent,
You raise some good problems. You may want to add yourself to the cc list
of an existing bug:
https://bugs.eclipse.org/bugs/show_bug.cgi?id=144210
regarding providing a public API for parsing OCL documents. Evidently, the
internal API that you are currently using also has problems.
Could you please raise bugs for:
- the problem in the grammar file of classifier context not replicating
invOrDefCS
- the exception complaining that the 'self' context cannot be redefined
I can't promise fixes in time for the 1.0.1 release, but we'll see.
Thanks,
Christian
Laurent Le Goff wrote:
> Hello,
> I would like to extends my meta-model with constraints AND new Operation.
> I've chosen OCL language.
> I have some trouble to compile OCL expressions.
> I want to edit an ocl file like this :
> package test
> context TestClass def:
> test1(t:String): String =
> 'coucou1'.concat(t)
> def:
> test2(t:String): String =
> 'coucou2'.concat(t)
> endpackage
>
> I've tried to compile these definition. the Parser send me an error :
> misplace construct. I've rewritten the OCL with only one definition :
> package test
> context TestClass def:
> test1(t:String): String =
> 'coucou'.concat(t)
> endpackage
>
> The parser compile this expression with success. And I can invoke test2
> operation later, GREAT!
>
> PROBLEM :
> I would like to define and compile some OCL constraints or operation (inv
> or def) from files. And call these operations or constraints from other
> files or String like this
>
> IOCLHelper helper = HelperUtil.createOCLHelper();
> EObject context = (EObject)resource.getContents().get(0);
> helper.setContext(TestPackage.eINSTANCE.getTestClass());
>
> OCLExpression exp;
> // where exp is the compilation of the OCL file with constraints and
> operation
> exp = ExpressionsFactory.eINSTANCE.createOCLExpression(expressionS tring);
> System.out.println(helper.evaluate(context, "self.test1('toto')"));
> System.out.println(helper.evaluate(context, "self.test2('toto')"));
>
> ** First I've look at the grammar in your OCL plugin (OCLLPGParser.g
> :lpg grammar) and I think that this grammar block me (extended bnf
> :notation):
>
> package -> 'package' pathName context+ 'endpackage'
> | context*
>
> context -> classifierContext
> | operationContext
> | propertyContext
>
> classifierContext -> context pathName invOrDef
> ...
>
> * I would need this :
>
> classifierContext -> context pathName invOrDef+
>
> ** Secondly I've tried to do this in another way, I've rewritten the code
> : package test
> context TestClass def:
> test1(t:String): String =
> 'coucou1'.concat(t)
> context TestClass def:
> test2(t:String): String =
> 'coucou2'.concat(t)
> endpackage
>
> The parser accept this code but there's an exception thrown that tell me
> that 'self' (context) can't be redefined.
>
> The only solution that I saw is to re-run the parser with each new 'def'
> or 'inv:'. I don't like this solution.
>
> Please, Does anybody know how can I find the good way to compile OCL
> Expressions?
>
> Sorry for the long mail.
> Thanks for any helps
>
> Regards
> Laurent
|
|
|
| Re: OCL compilation [message #590507 is a reply to message #49196] |
Fri, 08 September 2006 07:53 |
Laurent LE GOFF
Messages: 15
Registered: July 2009 |
Junior Member |
|
|
hello Christian,
thanks for your answer. I entered bugs in bugzilla:
* grammar restriction
https://bugs.eclipse.org/bugs/show_bug.cgi?id=156656
* 'self' cannot be redefine
https://bugs.eclipse.org/bugs/show_bug.cgi?id=156657
I hope that bugs will have to be resolved in the next version ;-)
Regards
Laurent
Le Thu, 07 Sep 2006 15:29:00 -0400, Christian W. Damus a écrit :
>
> Hi, Laurent,
>
> You raise some good problems. You may want to add yourself to the cc list
> of an existing bug:
>
> https://bugs.eclipse.org/bugs/show_bug.cgi?id=144210
>
> regarding providing a public API for parsing OCL documents. Evidently, the
> internal API that you are currently using also has problems.
>
> Could you please raise bugs for:
> - the problem in the grammar file of classifier context not replicating
> invOrDefCS
> - the exception complaining that the 'self' context cannot be redefined
>
> I can't promise fixes in time for the 1.0.1 release, but we'll see.
>
> Thanks,
>
> Christian
>
>
> Laurent Le Goff wrote:
>
>> Hello,
>> I would like to extends my meta-model with constraints AND new Operation.
>> I've chosen OCL language.
>> I have some trouble to compile OCL expressions.
>> I want to edit an ocl file like this :
>> package test
>> context TestClass def:
>> test1(t:String): String =
>> 'coucou1'.concat(t)
>> def:
>> test2(t:String): String =
>> 'coucou2'.concat(t)
>> endpackage
>>
>> I've tried to compile these definition. the Parser send me an error :
>> misplace construct. I've rewritten the OCL with only one definition :
>> package test
>> context TestClass def:
>> test1(t:String): String =
>> 'coucou'.concat(t)
>> endpackage
>>
>> The parser compile this expression with success. And I can invoke test2
>> operation later, GREAT!
>>
>> PROBLEM :
>> I would like to define and compile some OCL constraints or operation (inv
>> or def) from files. And call these operations or constraints from other
>> files or String like this
>>
>> IOCLHelper helper = HelperUtil.createOCLHelper();
>> EObject context = (EObject)resource.getContents().get(0);
>> helper.setContext(TestPackage.eINSTANCE.getTestClass());
>>
>> OCLExpression exp;
>> // where exp is the compilation of the OCL file with constraints and
>> operation
>> exp = ExpressionsFactory.eINSTANCE.createOCLExpression(expressionS tring);
>> System.out.println(helper.evaluate(context, "self.test1('toto')"));
>> System.out.println(helper.evaluate(context, "self.test2('toto')"));
>>
>> ** First I've look at the grammar in your OCL plugin (OCLLPGParser.g
>> :lpg grammar) and I think that this grammar block me (extended bnf
>> :notation):
>>
>> package -> 'package' pathName context+ 'endpackage'
>> | context*
>>
>> context -> classifierContext
>> | operationContext
>> | propertyContext
>>
>> classifierContext -> context pathName invOrDef
>> ...
>>
>> * I would need this :
>>
>> classifierContext -> context pathName invOrDef+
>>
>> ** Secondly I've tried to do this in another way, I've rewritten the code
>> : package test
>> context TestClass def:
>> test1(t:String): String =
>> 'coucou1'.concat(t)
>> context TestClass def:
>> test2(t:String): String =
>> 'coucou2'.concat(t)
>> endpackage
>>
>> The parser accept this code but there's an exception thrown that tell me
>> that 'self' (context) can't be redefined.
>>
>> The only solution that I saw is to re-run the parser with each new 'def'
>> or 'inv:'. I don't like this solution.
>>
>> Please, Does anybody know how can I find the good way to compile OCL
>> Expressions?
>>
>> Sorry for the long mail.
>> Thanks for any helps
>>
>> Regards
>> Laurent
|
|
|
Goto Forum:
Current Time: Wed Feb 05 16:49:43 GMT 2025
Powered by FUDForum. Page generated in 0.02530 seconds |
] 
Search
Help
Register
Login
Home
